[dragonraid] Re: [DragonRaid] Re: All -Out fun

Message: < previous - next > : Reply : Subscribe : Cleanse
Home   : December 2000 : Group Archive : Group : All Groups

From: William T Roberson III <robersonwt@...>
Date: Wed, 6 Dec 2000 17:15:20 -0500
Joe Roberson wrote:

"I take sword lessons..."  
Yes, but the katana is a light sword

"Yes that is two kills in under one second and
than finish the guy off by silting his neck.  "
Yes, but the katana is a fast sword

And remember, You are focused on putting out damage, not so much in
deflecting it.  You told me that feudal Japan had quiet battles, no
clanking.  The swords only hit flesh.  

Joe Revesz wrote:
"Impressive!  But, is that with a full pack and winter clothing?  What 
kind of classes are you taking?"
Whenever I play any role playing game, and from my experience in modern
combat training, I can tell you that the backpack is dropped very fast. 
Still, there is the fatigue of the journey.  But, please remember, this
is not G.U.R.P.S., where every little thing works for or against you. 
The purpose of this game is the scripture, and the Biblical lessons. 
Lightraiders are stronger than modern civilians, because their lives
depend on the ability to hike 50 miles with a full pack and then fight.
We do not need to worry about how tired a modern couch potato would get
after 3 minutes of swinging a lead pipe in the library at Colonel
Mustard.  We really don't need to worry about how many swings are in a
combat round.  The system is simple, and playable.  Any modifications
should be simple and playable.  One of the great points of this game is
that it is simple, and playable.
The thing that would be tragic would be if you had to roll to see if you
could make a special roll, then make that roll, then roll to see the
effect of that roll, and roll to see if the enemy could roll to take
advantage of the fact that you made a special roll, then roll for his
special roll, roll to see if that roll did something, and roll to see if
you could duck.  Trust me, too much rolling ruins a good game.  If the
All out Attack/Defense is playable, then allow it, without checks on a
chart.  

Just my (2 +1+3) 6 cents worth of input.

Ted Roberson

PS, why not cut you some quarterstaves (found in most wooded areas) and
test it with them, or watch a sword fighting movie, and see the combat. 
Remember, not every lightraider has a sword.